Culture is a strange thing. It is used in different ways by people. In the west according to their culture sons and daughters don't stay in their father's house. In India, they do. And for someone from the west, this part of the Indian culture, like most other parts, seems absurd. And the Indians who emigrated to the west, also find it absurd, because they now live in the west, among the forward-thinking, upwardly mobile, advanced civilization in the world. At least that is what we in the east secretly believe, when we have temporarily forgotten our great and glorious past, which we pit against that of the west when we feel at a disadvantage.
In the west we live among them, we live like them, we think like them, we talk like them, we keep their streets clean, follow their traffic rules to the hilt, build houses like theirs, adorn the walls with their art, celebrate their festivals, enjoy their sport, oh so many things and yet behind this facade we have an undying faith in our own greatness, in our own glorious past, in our scriptures and gods, in our family and social values. And at the same time we harbor deep within ourselves - it comes out only when we are back in India - a dislike of their tendency to waste, their lack of respect toward others, especially elders, their arrogance of the notion of a superior race, their ill-concealed contempt for the colored people, their laws, their extraordinary respect for the word of the law, their utter disregard for family values - we secretly believe they have none.
But when we come to India, alas, we see the filth on the streets, the dust in the house, the numerous slithering and crawling creatures on the walls, on the floor, on the tables - everywhere - in the corners, in the dark interiors, in claustrophobic places, and the utter disregard for rules, the chalta-hai attitude, the poverty - it is everywhere, not just in the shanties. Even the educated son is jobless, penniless, living in father's house, living off the largesse of his mother, living without rent, oh so many things, we see these things, like a daughter using her mother to look after the children, not caring for the health of the mother, using her as one would use a maid, and so on and so on. We see all this when we come to India and at once our mind rebels - there is a clash of cultures. The culture we have grown up with, but too hard to live down, too hard to live by, too hard to explain away, too hard to ignore, and the culture we are adopting now, living in now, living beautifully, organized, clean, salubrious, with dignity, with a fat bank balance, with opportunities to grow and bloom...something that is impossible in the homeland where children run amuck like monkeys, adults with their morals and principles long discarded by the west as foolish, silly and stupid, their respect for others and elders so much at odds with the canons of free spirit of the west. There is a clash. A clash that happens every time we visit India, every time, we walk or drive in the streets - the noise, the pollution, the filth, the chaotic traffic, the mind boggling numbers and variety of vehicles and pedestrians...a clash that is hard to reconcile, hard to live with, hard to bear, hard to ignore.
It is not the clash of two civilizations. It is not on a global scale. It is not news on BBC World Service. It is hardly noticed by the majority of the people in the world. They are not even aware of it. It is felt only by the emigrants, by those who are trying to fit into new clothes, into new streets, into new habitations. Those who are adjusting to their new surroundings, new faces, new society. It is a wholly different way of life. Mostly automated, works like a machine, with clockwork precision. This clash is felt by those who went over to the west. Leaving behind their fledgling homes in the backwoods, they went through the portals of opportunity into the high life, into the best places in the world, into the most sought after advanced human ecosystem.
It is felt in individuals, not in groups. It is felt by every man, woman and child. It is felt acutely when they return. It is felt every time we have to contend with the people we left behind...'left behind' is a phrase that is the motif of emigration. Those who emigrated to the west have progressed, went further in life, went ahead, metaphorically speaking. We have 'left behind' our unfortunate brothers and sisters, parents and relatives. And now when we return we feel the difference acutely, like we are entering into shanty town, into a hovel that was once our home, where we grew up, in ignorance, with silly aspirations and stupid notions. And now when we return we return not just to our homeland, not just to what was once our home, we return to our past, our shame, to live once again with misery, with uncleanness, with notions and superstitions, with brothers and sisters who have not 'grown' in the real sense, in the sense of growing, blooming, flowering. They are still in the dusty and ignorant past, the past we left behind, the past of murky and musty corridors, the past we left behind to the bright future of tomorrow. It is this we have to contend with. The clash of the past and the future, the clash that happens in the present, it happens now, it happens every time we meet them, we see them, we walk and talk with them. We become impatient with their old world notions, with their illogical explanations and irrational thoughts. We pity them, commiserate with their misfortune, live with their foolish notions and silly aspirations, put up with their inane talk, watch helplessly their useless struggles.
We suffer because we have experienced the clash, on account of them, because we bear the cross of their misfortune. We try to alleviate their misery with ideas and gifts so that they could organize their lives, improve their living conditions, live with more dignity, live in the modern world. But we see with exasperation that some of them are beyond rescue. Their ideas are too deeply entrenched in the past, their future is hopeless, meaningless, and entirely without significance. It is this clash that we have to bear, to suffer.
But the clash there needn't be. The clash is because they wouldn't change. The clash owes its genesis to a couple of individuals in the family who refuse to change, who are incapable of change, who are so utterly lacking in skills, so utterly old fashioned that they resist change and the clash happens. Not to them, they are blithely ignorant of it. They live their beastly little lives and expect us to live with them.
The clash is not just a conflict of the civilization. It is a clash at the very personal level. It centers around the home, the home we lived in, the home we left behind, the home we want to come back to. The home is no longer that home of our remembrances. It has changed so much that hardly is there anything to rekindle the fond memories. It is trodden over, trampled over like hooligans, desecrated, furniture destroyed, walls unpainted, fixtures broken, house distorted, backyard abandoned, litter all over the place. There is no welcome, no homecoming, just a guest staying at a sleazy motel with no amenities, no service, no telephone, no clean bed, the motel that is our home converted, corrupted. This is the clash that is hardest to bear, hardest to live down, hardest to talk about. This is a personal clash and I am sure every man and woman who left the shores of poverty to the opulence of paradise must have felt some time or other this mind deadening clash, this fist clenching clash, this clash that would never go away, never leave us alone, like a leech it hung on. Until we return sad and defeated, to our promised land of plenty, of order, of dignity.
Showing posts with label values. Show all posts
Showing posts with label values. Show all posts
Saturday, May 4, 2013
Friday, May 3, 2013
Funereal bitterness
He was reminiscing about his boyhood days in his village. They were three brothers and they worked together in collecting the harvest from the fields. Their mother would wake them up early in the morning and hustled them out to collect the grain into silos and stack them on the attic. The grain (kundulu?) was soaked in a pit full of water and watch it bloat into a dome. Then they would collect it into bags and shift them to the roof f the house. There it was spread to dry under the sun. The brothers arranged themselves in a line much like the workers at a building construction unit. Each would pass the other a bag until the last deposited it on the roof. This way they shifted the entire grain from the floor to the roof, one on the floor, the other somewhere halfway up on a ledge above a window and the last one on the roof.
He spoke of how he and his brothers helped their mother, how thick were the family ties, how good were the values then. He grew bitter as he reminisced more and began to attack the modern times which were bereft of those values, that respect for elders was utterly lacking, how the people became more selfish, self-centered and neglected the parents. He was perhaps betraying his own situation, but none of us mentioned it. He looked at me as he spoke, for he was sitting right across me.
I said that tradition, which was our inheritance, was much like the Roman god Janus, with one side of his face good and the other bad. You keep the good and throw the bad out. This remark somehow angered the brother and he fumed some more about declining morals and concern only with the self. There is no thought of God at all, he complained, his voice rising and his tone was bitter and angry. He got up from the chair, as if my very presence infuriated him. He found a chair a little away from me, far to my right and continued his ravings about how the society is changing for the worse. I was a little puzzled at his reaction, not sure ifi was the cause of it.
He said that people are now trying to step on the sun - at this my uncle and I suppressed laughter - and what arrogance, he says, that man should even think of it. I wanted to ask if man is not already walking on the earth and what is wrong in trying to do the same on another planet. I was not sure if he thought sun also was like another planet, or did he confuse with the moon? No. Sun and moon were the celestial beings and stepping on one I suppose gave us the arrogance to think of stepping on the other, which according to him was a sacrilege.
I did not pursue the topic. I saw clearly that the man was beyond himself with rage (at what precisely I could not gather). Another old man kept nodding at him as if he concurred, but it seemed to me more to pacify the irate brother. I kept my thoughts to myself and presently some activity of the funeral started and the man fell silent.
I wondered later why at that age - he was about seventy two or three, I was told - why such a person would grow bitter after having seen so much of life. My uncle, much older, nudging eighty, never showed any bitterness, although he suffered from the usual old age ailments, although he had lost his two sons to some disease, although he retired as a clerk and a pensioner. Why, why was that brother so bitter? What makes a man so bitter at the end of it all?
Is not the present handed down by those who lived in the past? Is it not the world that the young now live in, the very same world left by the self-righteous old men? The world that they shaped by their traditions, by their intelligence, by their beliefs and dogmas, by their successes and mistakes? Why does every generation decry the degeneracy that is present in their succeeding one? Is not the seed of degeneracy sown by the very same people who blithely disown it and point a finger of accusation at the present generation?
I think that the old are afraid that the beliefs they had held so dearly for decades are now exposed as sham, as hollow, as ineffectual in the tumultuous growth of the present, in its racy lifestyle, in its audacious inventions and discoveries? What exactly is the grouse of the old? Why are they always harping on values that they had lived by? Does it never occur to them that something was definitely wrong with those values that they didn't stand the test of time?
Man has become more selfish, the old man had said. Nothing could be further from the truth. But if the values that they had lived by were so great, then how did this situation come to pass? Evil influence, of course, the rise of the western culture, its incursions into the highly civilized societies of the east, and then the values crumbled, science grew and with it the many benefits and more opportunities to become rich, to come out of the rustic life of high morals...look at the young, he cried, look at them, they only think of themselves, they have no respect for the elders, for their parents. And so on and so on...the arguments go on and nothing comes from it. At the end there is only bitterness. An indigestion in the mind.
He spoke of how he and his brothers helped their mother, how thick were the family ties, how good were the values then. He grew bitter as he reminisced more and began to attack the modern times which were bereft of those values, that respect for elders was utterly lacking, how the people became more selfish, self-centered and neglected the parents. He was perhaps betraying his own situation, but none of us mentioned it. He looked at me as he spoke, for he was sitting right across me.
I said that tradition, which was our inheritance, was much like the Roman god Janus, with one side of his face good and the other bad. You keep the good and throw the bad out. This remark somehow angered the brother and he fumed some more about declining morals and concern only with the self. There is no thought of God at all, he complained, his voice rising and his tone was bitter and angry. He got up from the chair, as if my very presence infuriated him. He found a chair a little away from me, far to my right and continued his ravings about how the society is changing for the worse. I was a little puzzled at his reaction, not sure ifi was the cause of it.
He said that people are now trying to step on the sun - at this my uncle and I suppressed laughter - and what arrogance, he says, that man should even think of it. I wanted to ask if man is not already walking on the earth and what is wrong in trying to do the same on another planet. I was not sure if he thought sun also was like another planet, or did he confuse with the moon? No. Sun and moon were the celestial beings and stepping on one I suppose gave us the arrogance to think of stepping on the other, which according to him was a sacrilege.
I did not pursue the topic. I saw clearly that the man was beyond himself with rage (at what precisely I could not gather). Another old man kept nodding at him as if he concurred, but it seemed to me more to pacify the irate brother. I kept my thoughts to myself and presently some activity of the funeral started and the man fell silent.
I wondered later why at that age - he was about seventy two or three, I was told - why such a person would grow bitter after having seen so much of life. My uncle, much older, nudging eighty, never showed any bitterness, although he suffered from the usual old age ailments, although he had lost his two sons to some disease, although he retired as a clerk and a pensioner. Why, why was that brother so bitter? What makes a man so bitter at the end of it all?
Is not the present handed down by those who lived in the past? Is it not the world that the young now live in, the very same world left by the self-righteous old men? The world that they shaped by their traditions, by their intelligence, by their beliefs and dogmas, by their successes and mistakes? Why does every generation decry the degeneracy that is present in their succeeding one? Is not the seed of degeneracy sown by the very same people who blithely disown it and point a finger of accusation at the present generation?
I think that the old are afraid that the beliefs they had held so dearly for decades are now exposed as sham, as hollow, as ineffectual in the tumultuous growth of the present, in its racy lifestyle, in its audacious inventions and discoveries? What exactly is the grouse of the old? Why are they always harping on values that they had lived by? Does it never occur to them that something was definitely wrong with those values that they didn't stand the test of time?
Man has become more selfish, the old man had said. Nothing could be further from the truth. But if the values that they had lived by were so great, then how did this situation come to pass? Evil influence, of course, the rise of the western culture, its incursions into the highly civilized societies of the east, and then the values crumbled, science grew and with it the many benefits and more opportunities to become rich, to come out of the rustic life of high morals...look at the young, he cried, look at them, they only think of themselves, they have no respect for the elders, for their parents. And so on and so on...the arguments go on and nothing comes from it. At the end there is only bitterness. An indigestion in the mind.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)